The Kicked Out S-rank Appraiser Creates The Strongest Guild Novel Review

My Thoughts on The Kicked Out S-rank Appraiser Creates The Strongest Guild

First Impressions

Alright, let's dive into "The Kicked Out S-rank Appraiser Creates The Strongest Guild." From the get-go, it's clear this novel leans heavily into the "banished from the party" trope. We've seen it a million times: undervalued protagonist gets the boot, only to prove everyone wrong. And while the premise feels familiar, there's a certain comfort in that, like settling into a well-worn armchair. I came to this novel with tempered expectations, hoping for a fun, if not groundbreaking, read.

What Works Well

What I found surprisingly engaging was the MC's focus on appraisal and training. He's not suddenly OP in combat; his strength lies in identifying and nurturing talent. This sets it apart from other stories where the kicked-out character suddenly develops unbelievable fighting prowess. I appreciated that the MC's actions are more about adapting to a betrayal than a sudden, convenient power-up. The world-building, while not incredibly detailed, provides a solid backdrop for the guild management aspects of the story, which I found to be a nice change of pace. The core appeal of this story is the satisfaction of seeing the MC succeed by doing what he does best.

Areas of Concern

However, the story isn't without its flaws. The antagonists, in my opinion, often come across as one-dimensional and, frankly, a bit too foolish. It stretches believability that they would so readily discard someone so valuable. Furthermore, the MC, while skilled, can feel a bit generic and passive at times. I also found the writing style to be simplistic, which, while not a deal-breaker, doesn't elevate the story to its full potential. The frequent POV shifts can also be jarring and make it difficult to follow the narrative at times.

Final Verdict

Overall, "The Kicked Out S-rank Appraiser Creates The Strongest Guild" is an enjoyable read if you're a fan of the "banished" trope and looking for a relatively lighthearted adventure. While it doesn't reinvent the wheel, its focus on appraisal and guild management offers a fresh perspective. Just be prepared for some shallow characters and a straightforward plot. I'd recommend it as a casual read when you're in the mood for some satisfying, if predictable, storytelling.