Nidome no Jinsei wo Isekai de

My Thoughts on Nidome no Jinsei wo Isekai de

"Nidome no Jinsei wo Isekai de," or "Reincarnation in Another World," presents an intriguing concept: an elderly martial arts master gets a second shot at youth and adventure in a new world. While it has its high points, I found myself wrestling with some inconsistencies that kept me from fully embracing the story.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the premise of a mature protagonist in a genre often dominated by teenagers. The idea of a level-headed character navigating a fantasy world was appealing, and the early chapters held promise. There's a certain charm in seeing an old soul in a young body, especially when it's handled with nuance.

What Works Well

The protagonist's unique perspective, a blend of youthful vigor and seasoned wisdom, is a definite strength. Many have praised the MC for not being the typical spineless isekai protagonist. His internal conflicts, balancing his past as a battle-hardened warrior with his newfound youth, create a compelling dynamic. The world-building also stood out, with a sense of depth and intrigue that kept me invested. I appreciated the author's approach to battles, avoiding overly detailed descriptions and focusing on impactful moments. The initial comedic elements were also a plus, though those seem to fade as the story progresses.

Areas of Concern

However, I couldn't ignore some glaring inconsistencies. The biggest issue seems to be the protagonist's memory (or lack thereof). The narrative states his memories were wiped, yet he retains knowledge of his past life, which leads to logical questions and breaks immersion. Also, the MC's personality seems to fluctuate wildly, switching between a cold, calculating assassin and a naive teenager. This inconsistency makes it hard to connect with the character. Certain plot developments, particularly within the elf arc, have also been criticized for feeling poorly written and illogical. The translation quality is also a recurring concern, with some finding it riddled with errors.

Final Verdict

"Nidome no Jinsei wo Isekai de" had the potential to be a standout isekai novel, but inconsistencies in the protagonist's character and plot hamper the overall experience. While the world-building and mature MC offer some appeal, the logical leaps and translation issues ultimately detract from the story. I'd recommend approaching this novel with cautious optimism, ready to overlook certain flaws in favor of the intriguing premise.