Garudeina Oukoku Koukoku Ki Novel Review

My Thoughts on Garudeina Oukoku Koukoku Ki

This web novel definitely has its fans, and I can see why. "Garudeina Oukoku Koukoku Ki" offers a blend of classic fantasy elements with a kingdom-building twist, and the overpowered protagonist definitely appeals to a certain audience. However, it's not without its flaws, and I think it's important to go into it with realistic expectations.

First Impressions

The premise is undeniably interesting: a Japanese man reincarnated as a powerful dragonkin (Dragunir) who decides to build a nation for unjustly treated demi-humans. That setup alone is enough to pique my interest, and it seems to have hooked many other readers from the start. It’s a feel-good story with an OP main character fighting discrimination, and that’s a formula that often works.

What Works Well

The strongest aspect seems to be the focus on kingdom building rather than constant fighting. Many readers have praised the world-building and the protagonist's thoughtful approach to creating a sustainable and prosperous nation for beast-people. There's a heartwarming quality to the story, and the premise of a powerful being standing up for the oppressed is always appealing. I also appreciate that the MC isn't portrayed as a dense blockhead. He actually considers the feelings of those around him, which is a refreshing change from many similar novels.

Areas of Concern

Despite the positives, there are several areas where the novel seems to fall short. A recurring criticism is the quality of the writing. Some readers have described it as feeling like a summary rather than a fully fleshed-out story. The pacing can be disjointed, with significant time skips that gloss over important kingdom-building details.

Another concern is the protagonist's lack of common sense. While the "lack of common sense" tag might be initially appealing, it seems to manifest as illogical decisions and a general naivete that can be frustrating. The MC often acts impulsively without considering the consequences, which can undermine the sense of immersion. I've seen some readers questioning the logic behind his actions, especially regarding his dealings with slave traders and the handling of sensitive information.

Final Verdict

"Garudeina Oukoku Koukoku Ki" is a fun, easy-going read that's best enjoyed without thinking too hard about the finer details. It's a decent power fantasy with a heartwarming core, but the weak writing and illogical character decisions prevent it from reaching its full potential. If you're looking for a lighthearted kingdom-building story with an overpowered protagonist, this might be worth checking out. Just be prepared to suspend your disbelief and overlook some of the more glaring flaws.