Yes, My Class Is “Lumberjack”, So What? Novel Review
WE DO NOT HOST ANY CHAPTERS OR DOWNLOADS FOR THIS NOVEL.
By nodoguro, ノドグロ
81 chapters
2020
Description
Tendou Aoi was a normal girl who liked playing games. She was playing VRMMO『Genesis Frontier』when she found a quest to cut down a giant tree. The tree was too big for a person to cut. It took her about a year to clear the quest. The quest that no one thought could be cleared (even the game administrator). The enormous amount of Exp and Titles was granted to her as a reward. In one night, she suddenly got the same power as the top players in the game. But she was really confused, didn’t know what to do. Because until now, she had only been focused on cutting the tree down for one year. Thus she forgot how to play the game normally
Tags
Click any tag to find similar novels in the library
Publication Information
- Original Publisher
- syosetu
- Original Language
- japanese
- Type
- Web Novel
Yes, My Class Is “Lumberjack”, So What? Review & Spoilers - Novel Translator
My Thoughts on Yes, My Class Is “Lumberjack”, So What?
This web novel definitely piqued my interest with its quirky title and the promise of a unique gaming experience. While I found some aspects enjoyable, there are a few areas that held it back from being a truly standout read.
First Impressions
The premise is undeniably appealing. A lone wolf protagonist stumbles upon a ridiculously difficult, seemingly impossible quest in a VRMMORPG and, through sheer stubbornness, manages to complete it. The initial chapters had me hooked, reminding me a bit of BOFURI with its focus on unconventional character builds and unexpected rewards. I was eager to see how the MC would navigate the game with her overpowered stats but lacking real-world player skills.
What Works Well
I appreciated the concept of the "joke" quests yielding massive rewards. It's a fun twist on the standard game mechanics, and I enjoyed watching the MC exploit this loophole. The accelerated growth aspect, fueled by the quest rewards, was also engaging. Seeing her grapple with the disconnect between her character's power and her own inexperience was a compelling dynamic. The potential for character growth, as hinted at in the tags, was something I was definitely looking forward to exploring.
Areas of Concern
However, I found some issues with the MC's personality and the overall plot progression. Her constant self-deprecation and internal conflict felt somewhat forced and repetitive. While the "loner" trope can be interesting, it seemed to be inconsistently applied here, leading to some frustrating moments where she simultaneously craved and rejected social interaction.
The lack of a clear end goal for the MC also detracted from my enjoyment. While her initial focus on completing the impossible quest was engaging, her subsequent motivations felt less defined, leading to a sense of aimlessness in the later chapters.
Click "Reveal" to show spoiler content
Final Verdict
"Yes, My Class Is “Lumberjack”, So What?" has a lot of potential, and the initial chapters are genuinely entertaining. However, the inconsistencies in the MC's personality and the somewhat directionless plot, particularly towards the end, ultimately held it back. While the accelerated growth and unique quest mechanics are appealing, the forced angst and lack of a satisfying conclusion make it a mixed bag. I'd recommend it with reservations, primarily to readers who enjoy unconventional character builds and are willing to overlook some narrative shortcomings.
