The Spear User that Couldn’t Become the Hero 《Protagonist》

My Thoughts on The Spear User that Couldn’t Become the Hero 《Protagonist》

Okay, let's dive into "The Spear User that Couldn’t Become the Hero 《Protagonist》." This web novel definitely has a unique premise, and I can see why it's garnered some attention, but it also has some significant stumbling blocks.

First Impressions

The initial setup is intriguing. We're thrown into a world where weapon type dictates social standing and opportunity, which immediately sets up a classic underdog scenario for our spear-wielding protagonist. The story seems to be a subversion of the typical hero narrative, focusing on the "stepping stone" character rather than the chosen one. This premise had me hooked, promising a fresh take on familiar tropes.

What Works Well

I appreciate the story's attempt to deconstruct common light novel tropes. The idea of a protagonist who is actively "harmful to man" according to the established system is compelling. There's a clear intention to explore the struggles of the weak and misunderstood, the disposable soldiers often overlooked in grand hero narratives. The dual narrative structure, with the MC's story interwoven with the world's recorded history, is an ambitious touch that adds layers to the world-building. When the story focuses on the MC's struggles and heroism, it can be genuinely engaging.

Areas of Concern

However, the execution seems to be where things fall apart. The world-building, while intriguing in concept, apparently suffers from internal inconsistencies and plot holes. The "school system" and the logic behind it are criticized for feeling arbitrary and nonsensical. The tone is also a major point of contention. The attempts at romantic comedy clash with the supposedly dark, apocalyptic setting, creating a jarring disconnect. Characters sometimes act in ways that seem illogical or "dumbed down" for the sake of the plot, which can be frustrating. The conspiracy elements, intended to add depth, are described as underwhelming.

Final Verdict

"The Spear User that Couldn’t Become the Hero 《Protagonist》" presents an interesting premise with the potential for a compelling story. However, the execution is flawed, with inconsistencies in world-building, tonal issues, and questionable character motivations. While the story's attempts to subvert tropes are admirable, the result is a mixed bag. I'd say approach this one with caution and be prepared for a potentially frustrating read.