Everyone Else is a Returnee

My Thoughts on Everyone Else is a Returnee

"Everyone Else is a Returnee" is a web novel that I dove into with a mix of excitement and trepidation, given its high overall rating and diverse range of reader opinions. It’s a story about a protagonist left behind on Earth while everyone else is transported to another world to train for a coming apocalypse. The premise is intriguing and promises a unique take on familiar tropes, but does it deliver? Here's my take.

First Impressions

Initially, I was hooked by the concept. A loner, overlooked by the divine, gains immense power through sheer dedication and hard work. It's a classic underdog story with a twist. The early chapters had a certain charm, and I could see the appeal of a protagonist who becomes ridiculously overpowered.

What Works Well

Many readers, and I tend to agree, find the crafting aspect and the MC's dedication genuinely inspiring. There's a certain satisfaction in watching him meticulously hone his skills and create powerful artifacts. The novel also has a comedic element that, when it hits, can be quite entertaining. I appreciated the parodic nature of the story, with its self-aware jokes and references to other works. It doesn't take itself too seriously, which can be refreshing.

Areas of Concern

However, as I continued reading, I began to notice some significant flaws. Some feel the characters lack depth, and the MC, despite his immense power, can come across as bland and somewhat dense. The plot, at times, feels directionless and repetitive, with the MC simply grinding and overpowering enemies without any real sense of tension or stakes. The world-building, while initially promising, can feel inconsistent and underutilized. The humor, while intended to be a strength, sometimes falls flat or breaks the mood.

Final Verdict

"Everyone Else is a Returnee" has moments of brilliance and undeniable entertainment value. However, it suffers from inconsistent writing, shallow characters, and a repetitive plot. If you're looking for a lighthearted, overpowered protagonist story with a comedic twist, this might be worth a read. However, if you prefer more depth, complexity, and consistent world-building, you might find yourself disappointed. Ultimately, I'd say it's a decent read, but not the masterpiece some claim it to be.