If I Had To Say, I Would Say I Am A Evil Magician

My Thoughts on If I Had To Say, I Would Say I Am A Evil Magician

This web novel presents a mixed bag, and diving in requires a certain level of tolerance for initial awkwardness. While it eventually finds its footing, the early chapters might test your patience. It's definitely a story that demands you stick around for a bit before making a final judgment.

First Impressions

My first impression, based on the initial chapters, wasn't stellar. The protagonist, despite supposedly being a 200-year-old necromancer, comes across as more of an edgy teenager in how he responds to situations. Some moments intended for comedic relief, like the maid's constant insults, just felt off and undermined the MC's supposed "badass" persona. The academy setting felt forced, with students acting in ways that seemed illogical, creating unnecessary conflict.

What Works Well

Despite the initial struggles, I found that the story improves significantly as it progresses. The characters gain depth, and the plot begins to weave together in interesting ways. The dynamic between the MC and his doll maid, Mira, becomes a central focus, exploring themes of humanity and emotion. The author's writing style, while potentially affected by translation, manages to create a pleasing narrative flow that keeps you engaged. The unique perspective the MC brings to teaching dark magic becomes more apparent, offering a fresh take on the academy setting.

Areas of Concern

One recurring criticism is the MC's initial portrayal. His actions sometimes contradict his supposed age and experience, leading to a disconnect between his description and his behavior. This can be frustrating for readers expecting a cunning and powerful antihero. Additionally, the early conflicts feel forced and lack a clear purpose, making it difficult to invest in the story. The translation quality could also use some polishing, as some sentences come across as rough or awkwardly worded.

Final Verdict

"If I Had To Say, I Would Say I Am A Evil Magician" is a novel with potential that requires patience to unlock. The initial chapters are rough, but the story improves as it delves deeper into the characters and their relationships. If you're willing to overlook the initial flaws and stick around for a bit, you might find yourself enjoying this unique blend of action, comedy, and drama. However, if you're easily turned off by awkward beginnings or a seemingly weak protagonist, this might not be the story for you. I'd recommend giving it at least 20 chapters before making a final decision.