I Was Reincarnated as a Man Who Cuckolds Erotic Heroines, but I Will Never Cuckold Them (WN)

My Thoughts on I Was Reincarnated as a Man Who Cuckolds Erotic Heroines, but I Will Never Cuckold Them (WN)

This title definitely grabs your attention, doesn't it? I went into this web novel expecting a wild ride, and while it had its moments, it wasn't quite the rollercoaster I anticipated. It's a story about a guy reincarnated into a character destined to be the "other man" in an eroge, and his mission is to avoid that fate.

First Impressions

Initially, I was hooked by the premise. The idea of a character trying to subvert a pre-determined narrative, especially one with such a… specific theme, felt fresh. The early chapters really drew me in, especially the emotional backstory of the MC and his relationship with the main heroine, Ayane.

What Works Well

The emotional depth caught me off guard. I found myself invested in the characters' feelings and motivations. Ayane's character, in particular, is compelling. The story explores why she falls for the MC instead of the original protagonist, revealing layers to her personality that were only hinted at in the game. Some might even describe her as having yandere tendencies, which adds an interesting edge. I also appreciated the meta aspect of the story – the idea of characters in an NTR setting actually communicating and standing up for themselves.

Areas of Concern

While the initial emotional impact was strong, some readers felt the story lost its way after the initial conflict was resolved. The focus shifted to fluff and wrapping up loose ends, which might disappoint those looking for sustained drama. One point of contention is the MC's handling of the original protagonist, Chu. Some feel that the lack of communication and resolution of Chu's feelings is a major flaw, undermining the entire premise. Also, the flashbacks, while initially adding depth, can become repetitive and disrupt the pacing.

Final Verdict

Overall, I Was Reincarnated as a Man Who Cuckolds Erotic Heroines, but I Will Never Cuckold Them (WN) is an okay read. It starts strong with an intriguing premise and emotional depth, but it might lose some steam as it progresses. If you're looking for a story that subverts expectations and explores complex relationships, it's worth checking out, but be prepared for a potentially uneven experience.