A Banished Failure Survives in the Borderland and Becomes an S-Rank Exorcist

My Thoughts on A Banished Failure Survives in the Borderland and Becomes an S-Rank Exorcist

Alright, let's dive into "A Banished Failure Survives in the Borderland and Becomes an S-Rank Exorcist." With a title that long, you know you're in for something. I went in with an open mind, and here's what I found.

First Impressions

Honestly, the premise hooked me. An academy setting, betrayal, demons, and a banished protagonist trying to survive in a dangerous world? Sounds like my kind of story. However, I quickly noticed a trend in the reviews that gave me pause. Several readers pointed out issues with the protagonist's characterization and the overall pacing, which definitely tempered my initial excitement.

What Works Well

Despite some criticisms, there are definitely aspects to appreciate. The world-building seems interesting, with a post-apocalyptic fantasy setting that blends familiar RPG elements with a unique twist. A few readers have mentioned enjoying the interactions with demons and the unique power system, which suggests that the author has some cool ideas. The translation quality has also been highlighted as a positive, making the reading experience smoother. Some also find the side characters interesting.

Areas of Concern

Okay, let's address the elephant in the room: the protagonist. A common complaint is his inconsistent personality. Some feel he's portrayed as timid one moment and then suddenly becomes sarcastic or heroic, depending on the plot's needs. This lack of consistency makes it hard to connect with him, and it feels like the story dictates his character rather than the other way around. I've also seen some readers mention the pacing feels rushed, with plot points being resolved too quickly and lacking proper build-up. Dialogue is also another point of concern, with some readers finding it unnatural.

Final Verdict

"A Banished Failure Survives in the Borderland and Becomes an S-Rank Exorcist" has potential, but it's held back by inconsistent characterization and pacing issues. The world-building and translation are definite strengths, and if you can look past the protagonist's flaws, you might find it an enjoyable read. However, if you prioritize character development and a well-paced plot, this might not be the novel for you. I'd say it's a decent time-killer, but not a must-read.