The Author Reincarnated?! ~I’ll Become an Amazing Villain!~

My Thoughts on The Author Reincarnated?! I’ll Become an Amazing Villain!

"The Author Reincarnated?! I’ll Become an Amazing Villain!" is a web novel with a rather intriguing premise: a deceased author finds himself reborn as the villain in his own unfinished story. It's a concept ripe with potential for meta-commentary and self-aware storytelling, and that's what initially drew me in. However, after diving into the available chapters and considering the broader reader reaction, my feelings are mixed.

First Impressions

The initial hook of an author trying to steer his own narrative from the inside, so to speak, is undeniably appealing. I was excited to see how the protagonist, Carlo, would leverage his knowledge of the plot to become the ultimate villain. The idea of him manipulating events and characters to achieve his desired ending seemed like a promising setup for a unique and engaging story.

What Works Well

The core concept is definitely this novel's strongest asset. The potential for humor and clever plot twists is evident, and when the story focuses on the meta aspects of an author now living within their creation, it shines. Some readers have praised the story for its originality, particularly the dynamic of an author inhabiting a villain's body and trying to shape the narrative. I also appreciate the world-building, which, while not overly detailed, provides a solid foundation for the story to unfold.

Areas of Concern

Unfortunately, the execution seems to fall short for many, myself included. A recurring criticism revolves around Carlo's character. While he aims to be a villain, his actions often come across as naive, timid, or even contradictory to his stated goals. Several readers have pointed out that his attempts at villainy are often half-hearted or motivated by a desire to simply "finish the plot" rather than a genuine desire for power or control. This disconnect between his intentions and actions makes him difficult to root for, and at times, even frustrating to read.

Another point of contention is the pacing. Some readers find the story slow and lacking a sense of urgency. The magic system, while functional, is described as simplistic and uninspired. Finally, the translation, with its intrusive translator's notes, has been a major annoyance for some.

Final Verdict

"The Author Reincarnated?! I’ll Become an Amazing Villain!" has a compelling premise that unfortunately struggles to deliver on its potential. While the meta-narrative aspects are intriguing, the inconsistent characterization of the protagonist and the slow pacing ultimately detract from the overall experience. It's a novel that sparks curiosity but may leave you wanting more. I'd recommend approaching with cautious optimism, as your enjoyment will likely depend on your tolerance for a protagonist who seems unsure of his own villainous path.