Shimotsuki-san Likes the Mob (WN)

My Thoughts on Shimotsuki-san Likes the Mob (WN)

"Shimotsuki-san Likes the Mob" is definitely a web novel that evokes strong reactions. Diving in, I found myself understanding both the praise and the criticisms leveled against it. It's a unique story, but it's not without its flaws.

First Impressions

The initial premise is intriguing: a "mob character" protagonist, Koutarou, who's caught off guard when the popular Shimotsuki-san takes an interest in him. The setup has potential for a charming romance, especially with the added element of Koutarou's past relationships and his inferiority complex.

What Works Well

I found that Shimotsuki's character is often highlighted as a major strength. Her genuine affection for Koutarou, and her apparent immunity to the "harem protagonist's" charms, offer a refreshing dynamic. Many enjoy the interactions between the two, describing them as fluffy and heartwarming. The concept of her unique hearing ability, allowing her to perceive the "sound of the heart", is also a creative element that sets this story apart. Some readers also appreciate the initial concept of parodying harem tropes, viewing the narrative as a meta-commentary on the genre.

Areas of Concern

However, the execution seems to stumble in several areas. Koutarou's constant self-deprecation and repetition of "I'm a mob" can become grating and hinder character development. The "NTR" elements and Koutarou's past relationships are divisive, with some feeling they're poorly handled or even indicative of the author's... questionable tastes. The supporting characters are also often criticized for being unrealistic or frustratingly dense. The plot progression is slow with excessive internal monologues that drag on without adding much depth.

Final Verdict

"Shimotsuki-san Likes the Mob" is a mixed bag. The core romance between Koutarou and Shimotsuki has its moments, but the surrounding narrative is bogged down by repetitive tropes, frustrating characters, and a slow pace. The concept has potential, but the execution leaves much to be desired. I'd recommend approaching this with caution, and perhaps dropping it if the recurring issues become too overwhelming.