I Was Reincarnated as a Poor Farmer in a Different World, so I Decided to Make Bricks to Build a Castle Novel Review

My Thoughts on I Was Reincarnated as a Poor Farmer in a Different World, so I Decided to Make Bricks to Build a Castle

This title certainly grabbed my attention, and the premise of a reincarnated farmer building a castle sounded like a fun, lighthearted read. However, after diving into the available chapters and considering the general consensus, my feelings are a bit mixed.

First Impressions

Initially, the story seemed promising. The idea of a protagonist using modern knowledge to improve his lot in a fantasy world is always appealing. The magic system, with its unique "trademarking" aspect, also piqued my interest. I was ready to see how our MC would revolutionize brick-making!

What Works Well

The unique magic system is definitely a highlight. The concept of trademarking spells and the limitations it places on other users is an interesting twist. I also appreciate the translator's hard work, as many readers have pointed out the consistent and quick updates. For those looking for a simple, easy-to-follow story, this might fit the bill. The pacing is generally considered good, with events wrapping up within a few chapters.

Areas of Concern

Unfortunately, several issues hold this novel back. A major point of contention is the world-building, or rather, the lack thereof. The world feels incredibly shallow, with characters often appearing one-dimensional and lacking depth. I noticed several readers mentioned that the MC's family, including his parents and siblings, seem to pop up randomly with little to no backstory or established relationships.

The protagonist himself can be frustrating. Some find him bland and repetitive, with the story relying too heavily on his inner monologue. Others point out narcissistic tendencies, with the MC constantly praising himself. Plot holes also seem to be a recurring problem. Some found inconsistencies and illogical events that detract from the overall experience. The short chapter length can also exacerbate the feeling of repetition.

Final Verdict

"I Was Reincarnated as a Poor Farmer in a Different World, so I Decided to Make Bricks to Build a Castle" has potential, but ultimately falls short due to shallow world-building, inconsistent character development, and plot inconsistencies. While the unique magic system and dedicated translation are positives, the repetitive prose and simplistic storytelling may not appeal to all readers. If you're looking for a light, undemanding read and can overlook its flaws, it might be worth a try. Otherwise, there are likely better options available.