I Want To Be A Magic Sword Blacksmith!

My Thoughts on I Want To Be A Magic Sword Blacksmith!

Alright, let's dive into "I Want To Be A Magic Sword Blacksmith!" This novel had a lot of potential, and while it does some things well, there are also a few areas where it stumbles. I've read a few chapters, and I wanted to give my honest opinion.

First Impressions

The premise is definitely intriguing. A blacksmith crafting magic swords in a fantasy world filled with demi-humans, demons, and even gods? Sign me up! The shounen vibe is strong, and the promise of action, adventure, and a bit of romance definitely piqued my interest. The manga adaptation also hinted at a visually appealing world, which is always a plus.

What Works Well

The world-building is engaging. The author clearly put thought into creating a diverse cast of characters and a rich history. The action sequences are also well-written and exciting, and I found myself invested in the protagonist's journey to become a master blacksmith. The hints of romance were sweet, especially the "love interest falls in love first" trope, which is always fun to read. The whole "hiding true identity" aspect adds a layer of intrigue, keeping you guessing about what's to come.

Areas of Concern

My biggest issue is the translation quality. It's a real shame because a poor translation can completely ruin a story, and that's a risk here. It can be difficult to fully immerse yourself in the world when the writing feels clunky or unnatural. This issue can really detract from the overall experience.

Final Verdict

"I Want To Be A Magic Sword Blacksmith!" has a lot of potential. The world-building, action, and romance elements are all well-executed. However, the quality of the translation is a significant concern. If you're willing to overlook the translation issues, there's a fun story here to enjoy. Otherwise, you might want to wait and see if the translation improves before diving in. Overall, I'd give it a cautious recommendation.