Eight Desolate Sword God

My Thoughts on Eight Desolate Sword God

Eight Desolate Sword God is a novel that seems to have a bit of a love-it-or-hate-it vibe, and after diving into what others have said, I can see why. It's a xuanhuan story that doesn't shy away from classic tropes, which can be a blessing or a curse depending on your taste.

First Impressions

Right off the bat, a lot of readers have pointed out the familiar setup. We're talking about a protagonist who starts off as a genius, faces a fall from grace, and then stumbles upon a convenient power-up. The "mysterious brain" inheritance, in particular, has been singled out as a major cliché, granting instant comprehension and OP abilities. I can definitely see how this could feel uninspired to those looking for something fresh.

What Works Well

Despite the initial concerns, some readers, including myself, have found enjoyment in the story. AlaTheScribe, for example, felt that the author manages to reuse familiar tropes in a refreshing way. Even adsegm, who admits the novel is a "cliched wreck," couldn't bring themselves to drop it entirely. There's something to be said for a story that, despite its flaws, keeps you coming back for more. I see potential in the way the MC actively seeks opportunities for growth, which is a nice contrast to the passive, pie-in-the-sky beginnings.

Areas of Concern

One of the biggest criticisms revolves around the protagonist himself. Several readers have described the MC as "ret*rded," "bipolar," and "hypocritical," particularly regarding his attitude towards women and cultivation. The perceived inconsistencies in his character and the plot armor that seems to protect him from the consequences of his actions have also been sources of frustration. The power scaling and talent distribution also seem to be inconsistent.

Final Verdict

Eight Desolate Sword God is a bit of a mixed bag. If you're a seasoned xuanhuan reader looking for something groundbreaking, this might not be it. However, if you enjoy classic tropes, don't mind some inconsistencies, and are looking for a story to switch your brain off to, this could be worth a shot. Just be aware of the potential pitfalls and prepare for a potentially bumpy ride.