Why Harem Intrigue When You Can Just Raise a Dog Instead Novel Review

My Thoughts on Why Harem Intrigue When You Can Just Raise a Dog Instead

"Why Harem Intrigue When You Can Just Raise a Dog Instead" certainly has a title that grabs your attention! I dove into this novel with a mix of excitement and trepidation, given the mixed bag of opinions I'd seen. Overall, it's a story with a lot of potential, but some significant flaws that held it back from being a truly great read for me.

First Impressions

The premise is undeniably unique. A transmigration story where the female lead treats the emperor, unknowingly trapped in a dog's body, with kindness? I was immediately intrigued. The initial chapters are fairly lighthearted, focusing on the interactions between the MC and the "dog emperor," which is undeniably cute and funny. I found myself enjoying the dynamic and the potential for a satisfying romance.

What Works Well

Many readers praised the female lead, and I agree! She's intelligent, perceptive, and prioritizes her family's well-being. I loved that she wasn't easily swayed by the emperor's affections, especially after his past actions. Her pragmatism and ability to navigate the treacherous harem politics were definitely highlights for me. The author's writing style is also commendable. The translation quality is excellent, and the story is generally well-paced. The intrigue is present but doesn't overwhelm the romance, which is a nice balance.

Areas of Concern

However, the male lead is where I started to have issues. While the "dog" phase is endearing, the emperor's past actions are difficult to overlook. He initially used the MC, gave her birth control, and favored others, making it hard to root for him even after his supposed redemption. His behavior, even after regaining his human form, is often described as annoying, self-centered, and borderline entitled. I struggled to believe in his transformation and found myself sympathizing with the MC's hesitation to accept his affections. The age of the female lead and the emperor's actions while she was so young were also problematic and made me uncomfortable.

Final Verdict

"Why Harem Intrigue When You Can Just Raise a Dog Instead" is a mixed bag. The unique premise and strong female lead are definite strengths, but the problematic male lead and questionable power dynamics hinder its overall appeal. If you can overlook these flaws, you might find this a cute and satisfying romance. However, if you are sensitive to these issues, this might not be the novel for you.