When I was Reincarnated into a Game World, I Was a Farmer’s Son Novel Review
WE DO NOT HOST ANY CHAPTERS OR DOWNLOADS FOR THIS NOVEL.
By rōto, ろうと
195 chapters
2022
Description
This story follows a young farmer’s boy named Neil that live peacefully in a farming village called Machikane. One day, when he go out to play behind his house, he got too careless and fell down a cliff. Neil parent’s, Doug and Mylene are really worried of him, but thankfully, he is not seriously injured. However, from that fall, Neil starts to remember things that he shouldn’t. From that incident, Neil begins to recall the memories of his previous life as Yamada Keiichi. Overwhelmed by the thought of reincarnation, Neil tries to gather information about the world he is currently living in…
Tags
Click any tag to find similar novels in the library
Publication Information
- Original Publisher
- kakuyomu
- Original Language
- japanese
- Type
- Web Novel
When I was Reincarnated into a Game World, I Was a Farmer’s Son Review & Spoilers - Novel Translator
My Thoughts on When I was Reincarnated into a Game World, I Was a Farmer’s Son
Alright, let's dive into "When I was Reincarnated into a Game World, I Was a Farmer’s Son." With a premise like that, I was hoping for a charming underdog story, maybe a bit of a slow burn with some clever twists. The reality, at least based on my reading and the general consensus so far, is a bit more complicated.
First Impressions
The initial chapters painted a picture of a simple, almost idyllic life juxtaposed with the harsh realities of survival in a fantasy world. The idea of a reincarnated soul stuck as a farmer's son definitely has potential. I was intrigued to see how the protagonist would navigate this new reality, especially with the "game world" aspect hanging in the background.
What Works Well
The novel does a decent job of establishing the protagonist's humble beginnings. The early chapters effectively convey the struggles of a farmer's life. The world-building, while perhaps not groundbreaking, is serviceable enough to create a believable fantasy setting. I appreciated the focus on character growth, even if it felt a bit slow. The presence of demons, dungeons, and empires hints at a larger, more exciting world waiting to be explored.
Areas of Concern
Unfortunately, there were some significant issues that held me back from fully enjoying the story. The pacing felt incredibly slow, with repetitive descriptions and explanations that didn't always contribute to the plot. The protagonist's decision-making also left something to be desired. His lack of ingenuity when it came to basic survival skills felt jarring, especially considering his past life knowledge. The family dynamic, while present, felt a bit underdeveloped. The lack of suspicion regarding the MC's strange food choices was immersion-breaking.
Click "Reveal" to show spoiler content
Final Verdict
"When I was Reincarnated into a Game World, I Was a Farmer’s Son" has a promising premise, but ultimately falls short due to pacing issues, repetitive writing, and questionable character decisions. While there are glimpses of potential, the slow progress and frustrating protagonist make it a difficult read. At 2.9/5, it's clear that others have shared similar sentiments. I'm hoping the author can address these concerns and unlock the story's true potential, but as it stands, I'm hesitant to continue.