The God of Sky & Earth

My Thoughts on The God of Sky & Earth

"The God of Sky & Earth" promised a grand xuanhuan adventure, and while it had moments that shone, my overall experience was mixed. The novel presents a male protagonist, Su Yi, navigating a world of cultivation, demons, and arranged marriages. However, some choices made by both the character and the author left me scratching my head.

First Impressions

Right from the get-go, the story throws you into the deep end. The initial premise, involving Su Yi's past actions and subsequent exile, is… controversial, to say the least. It certainly grabs your attention, but not necessarily in a good way. I found myself questioning the protagonist's moral compass early on, which made it difficult to fully invest in his journey.

What Works Well

Despite my initial reservations, the novel does have its strengths. I appreciated the fast-paced cultivation and the glimpses of a unique magical space. There were hints of something truly epic, especially during Su Yi's adventures in the demon forest. The potential for a fresh take on the xianxia genre was definitely there. I also found his mysterious cultivation technique interesting and that the MC wasn't chasing after every girl he saw.

Areas of Concern

Unfortunately, the potential wasn't always realized. Several aspects of the story felt generic, from the endless stream of "young master" antagonists to the seemingly pointless reincarnation element. The protagonist's decision-making often left me bewildered. His stubborn determination to marry a girl who actively wants him dead, and then joining a sect where everyone is trying to kill him, felt incredibly contrived.

Final Verdict

"The God of Sky & Earth" has flashes of brilliance and a potentially engaging world. However, the problematic protagonist, reliance on tired tropes, and questionable plot decisions ultimately hold it back. While some readers might find enjoyment in its fast pace and moments of epic action, I would caution others to approach with tempered expectations. Ultimately, I'd rate it a 3 out of 5. It's a novel with potential, but one that needs significant refinement to truly shine.