Peter Pan and Cinderella

My Thoughts on Peter Pan and Cinderella

Alright, let's dive into "Peter Pan and Cinderella." This novel definitely evokes some strong reactions, and I can see why. It's a showbiz romance with a focus on misunderstandings and doting older siblings, which is catnip for some readers, including me. I went in expecting a fun, fluffy read, and while I got some of that, it wasn't quite what I anticipated.

First Impressions

Initially, I was charmed. The premise is intriguing: a naive, somewhat bratty young master (Wang Chao) in the entertainment industry falling for a more mature and aloof character (Xie Zhuxing). The early chapters are filled with comedic misunderstandings, mostly stemming from Wang Chao's, shall we say, unique way of interpreting situations. The dynamic between the brothers is also hilarious, especially their over-the-top protectiveness.

What Works Well

The characters are undoubtedly the strongest aspect. Wang Chao, despite his flaws, is incredibly endearing. His genuine kindness and devotion, even when misguided, make him hard to dislike. Xie Zhuxing is a good foil, providing a calm and steady presence to Wang Chao's whirlwind of emotions. I also appreciate that Xie Zhuxing isn't just another cookie-cutter cold CEO; he has a gentle side that peeks through. The humor is also a big plus. There are moments of pure comedic gold, especially involving the brothers. It's definitely a light read that doesn't drag on, which I appreciate.

Areas of Concern

However, I can't ignore some of the criticisms. The plot can feel messy at times, with events and drama piling on without clear resolution. I also felt like the dynamic between the leads becomes unbalanced. Wang Chao invests so much and tries so hard and it feels like the other MC does not reciprocate in kind. And I agree that some of the "gag" moments, where Wang Chao is treated poorly, cross the line from funny to uncomfortable.

Final Verdict

"Peter Pan and Cinderella" is a bit of a mixed bag. It has moments of genuine charm, humor, and heartwarming character interactions. However, the messy plot and some questionable plot choices hold it back from being a truly exceptional read. I'd recommend it with reservations, especially if you're a fan of the "bratty shou/mature gong" dynamic and can overlook some of the problematic elements. Proceed with caution.