Not Super Robot Wars at All Novel Review

My Thoughts on Not Super Robot Wars at All

"Not Super Robot Wars at All" is quite a ride, and I mean that in the most exhilarating and occasionally bumpy way possible. As someone who enjoys a good mecha story, especially when it plays with established universes, this novel definitely piqued my interest. It's a fanfiction at its core, mashing together various Gundam timelines with elements from Code Geass, Evangelion, and more. The result is a wild, often emotionally charged, narrative that kept me hooked despite some of its quirks.

First Impressions

Initially, the sheer number of series being thrown into the mix felt a bit overwhelming. It's a bold move to try and create a cohesive world out of so many different universes, but the author does put in the effort to integrate them believably. The protagonist, an OC who quickly becomes a mecha development genius, felt like a classic isekai character, but with a twist: his "cheat" abilities often lead to more suffering than power.

What Works Well

The emotional drama is definitely a highlight. The author isn't afraid to delve into the darker sides of these characters, exploring their flaws and vulnerabilities in ways that feel surprisingly realistic, even within the heightened setting. The harem aspect, while present, isn't just mindless wish fulfillment. The relationships are complex, filled with conflict, and have a tangible impact on the story and the protagonist's sanity. I particularly appreciated how the heroines retained their own personalities and agendas. It's clear the author cares about the source material, even when taking liberties with it. The world-building, despite its complexity, is impressive. The integration of different power systems and lore is generally well-executed, creating a unique and engaging plot.

Areas of Concern

While I enjoyed the character development, some of the personality shifts felt a bit extreme, almost as if they were solely for the sake of adding more drama. Also, the ending leaves something to be desired. It felt rushed and unsatisfying, especially after investing so much time in the characters and their struggles.

Final Verdict

Despite its flaws, "Not Super Robot Wars at All" is a compelling read for fans of mecha anime and those who enjoy complex, character-driven stories. The author's passion for the genre shines through, and the unique world-building and emotional depth make it a memorable experience. I'd give it a solid 4 out of 5 stars. Just be prepared for some potentially uncomfortable themes and a somewhat abrupt ending.