Nishino – The Boy At The Bottom Of The School Caste And Also At The Top Of The Underground

My Thoughts on Nishino – The Boy At The Bottom Of The School Caste And Also At The Top Of The Underground

This novel certainly presents an intriguing premise: a high schooler who's secretly an overpowered hitman navigating the treacherous waters of school social hierarchies. "Nishino" blends action, school life, and a dash of the supernatural, promising a unique reading experience. However, after diving into the available information and reading through various opinions, I'm left with mixed feelings.

First Impressions

The initial concept is undeniably captivating. We have an MC who's seemingly at the bottom of the school's social ladder, yet simultaneously at the top of a dangerous underground world. This duality immediately creates a hook, making you wonder how these two lives intertwine and what conflicts arise. The idea of a protagonist wanting a normal high school life despite his extraordinary circumstances is quite appealing.

What Works Well

Several elements stand out as potential strengths. The protagonist's desire for a "normal" high school experience, despite his hitman background, offers a unique dynamic. I appreciate the potential for character growth as he navigates social interactions and grapples with his dual identity. Some readers have praised the comedic aspects, especially the MC's somewhat awkward and "cringe" interactions. The yandere heroine seems to be a popular point of interest for many, adding another layer of intrigue to the story. Also, the characters start to see him with more respect is a nice detail.

Areas of Concern

Despite the promising premise, several reviewers raised concerns that I can't ignore. A recurring criticism is the execution of the characters, with some finding them bland or unlikeable. The MC's motivations and actions are questioned, particularly his willingness to be "bullied" despite his immense power. The yandere heroine's role is also criticized, with some feeling she doesn't actively support the MC. Another common complaint is the lack of depth in exploring the MC's hitman job and the intricacies of his powers. Finally, the translation quality of certain volumes has been flagged as problematic, potentially hindering the reading experience.

Final Verdict

"Nishino – The Boy At The Bottom Of The School Caste And Also At The Top Of The Underground" presents an interesting blend of genres and a unique protagonist. However, the execution appears to be inconsistent, with concerns raised about character development, plot coherence, and translation quality. While the premise and comedic elements may appeal to some, others might find the characters and their interactions frustrating. Ultimately, whether you enjoy this novel will likely depend on your tolerance for flawed characters and your appreciation for its specific brand of humor and ecchi elements. It's a potentially entertaining read, but be aware of its shortcomings before diving in.