It’s Not Bad Luck with Guys—You Just Have Catastrophically Terrible Taste in Men!

My Thoughts on It’s Not Bad Luck with Guys—You Just Have Catastrophically Terrible Taste in Men!

This title definitely grabbed my attention, and diving into the story, I found a rather unique premise. It's a blend of comedy, romance, and a touch of the psychological, all wrapped up in a modern-day setting that follows our male protagonist through high school, college, and into the workforce. The core concept revolves around a guy whose crushes consistently fall for, shall we say, less-than-ideal men.

First Impressions

Initially, I was intrigued by the potential for humor and character development. The idea of a protagonist navigating a series of romantic near-misses, where the girls he likes end up with absolute scumbags, had me curious. Was this going to be a hilarious train wreck or a surprisingly insightful commentary on relationships?

What Works Well

The humor is definitely a strong point. The protagonist's almost detached, straight-laced personality as he deals with these situations provides a lot of comedic relief. It's the kind of humor that comes from the absurdity of the situations he finds himself in. And, let's be honest, there's a certain satisfaction in seeing these awful boyfriends get their comeuppance, even if our MC is the one inadvertently helping to bring it about. I also appreciate the multiple arcs, showing the MC through different stages of his life. It allowed the story to evolve beyond just high school drama.

Areas of Concern

While the humor is enjoyable, I can see how the premise might not appeal to everyone. The MC's "goody-two-shoes" tendencies, as one reader put it, could be irritating if you're not a fan of characters who consistently help those who have wronged them. Also, some might find the constant cycle of the MC's crushes falling for terrible men repetitive.

Final Verdict

Overall, "It’s Not Bad Luck with Guys—You Just Have Catastrophically Terrible Taste in Men!" is a mixed bag. If you're looking for a lighthearted, comedic read with a unique premise, and you don't mind a protagonist who sometimes makes questionable decisions out of pity, this might be worth checking out. However, if you're easily annoyed by tropes, or if you're looking for a straightforward romance, this probably isn't for you. I'd give it a tentative recommendation, but with the caveat that you need to be in the right mood to fully appreciate its bizarre charm.