It’s Nice to Have a Romcom, But the Heroines Are Nothing but Monsters

My Thoughts on It’s Nice to Have a Romcom, But the Heroines Are Nothing but Monsters

This title grabbed my attention immediately. A romcom where the heroines are…monsters? I had to dive in. After reading a good chunk of the available chapters, I've got some thoughts.

First Impressions

The initial premise is definitely unique. We have an average-looking protagonist who, for some reason, perceives the seemingly normal girls around him as grotesque monsters. It’s a fascinating twist on the typical harem setup, and the mystery surrounding why he sees them this way is compelling. The story immediately throws you into the deep end, leaving you questioning reality right alongside the MC.

What Works Well

The world-building, or rather, the unveiling of the world, is particularly well done. The author does a great job of creating a sense of unease and uncertainty. Are these girls truly monsters? Is the protagonist hallucinating? Is there a deeper supernatural element at play? This ambiguity keeps me hooked. I also appreciate that the “monster girls” aren’t just your run-of-the-mill anime tropes with a monster skin slapped on. They are genuinely monstrous in appearance, which adds a layer of dark humor and intrigue to the romcom elements. The translation quality is also noteworthy; it's smooth and easy to read, which is always a huge plus.

Areas of Concern

While the mystery is intriguing, at times I felt the protagonist's reactions were a little…detached. It created a sense that something was missing. While his calm demeanor is a key element, I sometimes found it hard to fully connect with his internal struggles. I also worry that the "romance" aspect feels a bit one-sided, since the MC is understandably horrified by the girls' true forms. I hope the author explores the emotional complexities of this situation further.

Final Verdict

"It’s Nice to Have a Romcom, But the Heroines Are Nothing but Monsters" is a unique and entertaining read. The intriguing mystery, monstrous heroines, and high-quality translation make it stand out. While I have some reservations about the protagonist's emotional depth and the potential imbalance in the "romance," I'm invested enough to see where the story goes. If you're looking for a romcom with a dark twist and a healthy dose of mystery, this might be right up your alley.