I Will Not Choose You~ I Want to Cut Ties With His Highness and Go See My Favorite! Why Does My Older Brother Dote on Me?

My Thoughts on I Will Not Choose You~ I Want to Cut Ties With His Highness and Go See My Favorite! Why Does My Older Brother Dote on Me?

This title is a mouthful, isn't it? "I Will Not Choose You~ I Want to Cut Ties With His Highness and Go See My Favorite! Why Does My Older Brother Dote on Me?" promises a fun, trope-filled ride through a villainess reincarnation story. And, for the most part, it delivers, but with some caveats that are hard to ignore.

First Impressions

The premise is certainly intriguing. A reincarnated villainess, a doting brother, a prince she wants nothing to do with, and a favorite she'd rather be chasing after? It screams chaotic fun. I was immediately drawn in by the potential for humor and the promise of a female lead who knows what she wants (even if it's not what everyone expects).

What Works Well

The story definitely leans into the villainess trope, and that's where it shines. The female lead is headstrong and determined to avoid the pitfalls of her past life. The initial setup is compelling, and the author creates a world that feels both familiar and unique within the genre. The plot moves at a decent pace, and there are enough twists and turns to keep you engaged.

Areas of Concern

However, there's a significant element that some readers might find problematic: the romantic relationship with her brother. While it's stated they aren't blood-related, the initial dynamic is undeniably that of siblings, and the shift into a romantic relationship can feel unsettling. The way this relationship develops, with one party being unaware of the lack of blood relation, raises some serious red flags.

Additionally, the antagonists, particularly the crown prince, can feel a bit one-dimensional. Their motivations aren't always clear, and their actions sometimes seem driven more by plot convenience than genuine character development. This can make the conflicts feel less impactful and the female lead's struggles less meaningful.

Final Verdict

"I Will Not Choose You~ I Want to Cut Ties With His Highness and Go See My Favorite! Why Does My Older Brother Dote on Me?" is a mixed bag. If you're looking for a lighthearted villainess story with a unique romantic twist (or a twist that might make you squirm), you might find enjoyment here. However, be prepared for some potentially uncomfortable themes and underdeveloped antagonists. Proceed with caution, and be aware of the content warnings before diving in. I'd say it's a solid 3/5 stars.