I Saw a Smile

My Thoughts on I Saw a Smile

"I Saw a Smile" promised a sweet escape into a high school romance, and while it had moments that sparkled, my overall experience was a bit more lukewarm. As someone who enjoys a good dose of shoujo fluff, I went in hoping for a lighthearted, feel-good story.

First Impressions

The initial chapters definitely set a cute tone. The premise of a girl experiencing her first love in high school is always appealing, and the writing style does lean into that shoujo manga aesthetic. It's easy to read and the translation flows well, which is always a plus. I could see the potential for a charming and addictive read.

What Works Well

The story's strength lies in its simplicity. If you're looking for a quick and easy read to satisfy a craving for light romance, this might just hit the spot. The focus on the female protagonist's perspective makes it relatable, especially for those who enjoy josei stories. There's an undeniable sweetness to the interactions, and I appreciated that it didn't try to be something it wasn't.

Areas of Concern

However, I have to admit that the plot felt somewhat plain. While simplicity can be a virtue, in this case, it bordered on being a bit boring. The story lacked that extra spark to truly captivate me. I also wished there was more depth to the characters and their relationships. While it's still ongoing, I'm hoping to see more development in the future.

Final Verdict

Ultimately, "I Saw a Smile" is a decent, easy read if you're in the mood for something light and fluffy. It has its charms, but it didn't quite reach its full potential for me. I'd recommend it with reservations, especially if you're a die-hard shoujo fan looking for a quick fix. But for those seeking a more complex and engaging story, this might not be the right fit. I'm giving it a tentative 3/5, hoping that future chapters will bring more substance to the narrative.