Himekishi ga Classmate! ~ Isekai Cheat de Dorei ka Harem~ Novel Review

My Thoughts on Himekishi ga Classmate! ~ Isekai Cheat de Dorei ka Harem~

Alright, let's dive into "Himekishi ga Classmate!" This one is... certainly something. Going in, you absolutely need to know what you're getting into: this is an R18 novel, and that aspect is very forward. If you're looking for high fantasy with intricate world-building, you're in the wrong place. But if you're here for the erotica with a side of isekai, then keep reading.

First Impressions

My initial reaction was definitely a bit of shock. The premise is... well, it's out there. A classroom of people die and reincarnate into another world, and our MC gains the ability to enslave women. It's a bold start, to say the least, and not for the faint of heart. The story throws you right into the thick of it, and the tone is set immediately.

What Works Well

Honestly, for what it is, the novel isn't terrible. The s*x scenes are clearly a major focus, and some readers found them well-written and varied. The protagonist, despite his questionable actions, is sometimes portrayed as a villain with heroic tendencies. He wants what he wants, but he doesn't actively seek to harm others unless provoked, which adds a layer of complexity, however thin. The plot, while not particularly deep, can be entertaining. The characters are varied, and some found that the author did a good job of giving them their own circumstances.

Areas of Concern

Look, there's no getting around it: the premise is problematic. The MC's actions are often morally reprehensible, and that can be a major turn-off for many. Some readers found the plot nonsensical and the fight scenes poorly written. The character development, outside of the MC, is often lacking, with the harem members sometimes feeling like automatons. The story can feel repetitive and predictable, with the MC effortlessly winning every fight and adding new girls to his harem. Furthermore, the novel is currently on hiatus, leaving the story unresolved.

Final Verdict

"Himekishi ga Classmate!" is a very specific type of novel. If you're looking for a deep, meaningful story with well-developed characters and a strong moral compass, steer clear. However, if you're in the mood for an erotica-focused isekai with a morally gray protagonist and don't mind the problematic elements, you might find some enjoyment here. Just be prepared for a potentially unfinished story and a whole lot of questionable content. Personally, I'd say proceed with caution and manage your expectations accordingly.