General’s Gown

My Thoughts on General’s Gown

"General’s Gown" is a historical yaoi novel with a blend of mature themes and comedic undertones that I found myself surprisingly conflicted about. It has the classic enemies-to-lovers trope, a devoted love interest, and a general setting that usually pulls me right in. However, some aspects didn't quite land as well as I'd hoped.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the promise of a cunning, flirtatious ML paired with an upright, honorable MC. The banter between them is definitely a highlight, and I enjoyed the dynamic of a seemingly cold general slowly warming up to the ML's advances. The premise is interesting, and the early chapters set a good pace.

What Works Well

The ML, Helian Rongchuan, is a character many seem to adore. His shamelessness, humor, and unwavering devotion to the MC, Yan Changqing, are undeniably charming. I can see why so many readers find him lovable. Some readers mentioned that they love how he relentlessly pursues the MC. The plot moves along at a good clip, with enough intrigue to keep me invested. The translation quality is also excellent, which significantly enhances the reading experience.

Areas of Concern

My biggest issue, and one echoed by several other readers, lies in the portrayal of the MC. While he's supposed to be a strong and capable general, there are times when he seems inexplicably weak, often needing to be rescued. This inconsistency undermines his character and can be frustrating. I also felt that the story lacked emotional intimacy, especially in the later stages. The ending, while complete, left me wanting more of a payoff for the characters' struggles. Some readers also expressed concern regarding scenes that some found to be instances of sexual harassment.

Final Verdict

"General's Gown" is a mixed bag. While the ML's character and the overall plot have their charms, the inconsistencies in the MC's portrayal and the lack of emotional depth ultimately hold it back. If you're looking for a light read with a devoted ML and can overlook some of the problematic elements, it might be worth a try. However, be aware of the potential triggers and temper your expectations accordingly. I would give it a 3/5. It has potential, but it doesn't quite reach the heights I was hoping for.