As if I’d Ever Be a Magical-Girl Novel Review

My Thoughts on As if I’d Ever Be a Magical-Girl

"As if I’d Ever Be a Magical-Girl" presents a quirky premise: a guy who can transform into a plant-based magical girl. The story blends action, comedy, and gender-bending elements, and I found myself intrigued by its potential. However, after diving into the available chapters, I'm left with mixed feelings.

First Impressions

The initial chapters are definitely geared toward comedy. The series throws you right into the protagonist's world, where supernatural events are commonplace, and heroes are a necessity. Our MC is trying to retire from his magical girl gig, but life, of course, has other plans. The humor is front and center, and you'll likely know within the first chapter if the tone meshes with your tastes.

What Works Well

The comedic tone, when it hits, is genuinely entertaining. The author clearly aims for lighthearted fun, and many readers seem to appreciate the similar style to "Witch in a World of Urban Legends." I think the MC’s struggles with his dual identity and the absurd situations he finds himself in can be pretty funny. The world-building, while not overly detailed, effectively sets the stage for the story. It's a world where you just accept the weirdness and go with it.

Areas of Concern

While the humor is a major draw for some, it seems to fall flat for others. I can see how the elementary-school level humor might not appeal to everyone, especially when juxtaposed with more serious or even gory elements. There are also concerns about the plot feeling thin, with the MC's college life taking center stage while bigger threats loom in the background. Some readers may find the story lacks depth and development, especially regarding the gender-bending aspect, which is more of a comedic gimmick than a substantial plot point. Furthermore, the MC's situation with being a "slave protagonist" who is being mistreated and underpaid for his hero work is a point of contention.

Final Verdict

"As if I’d Ever Be a Magical-Girl" is a series with a lot of potential, particularly if you enjoy comedic superhero stories. However, its reliance on humor might not appeal to everyone, and some may find the plot and character development lacking. If you're looking for a lighthearted, silly read, this might be worth checking out. Just be aware that it might not be the most profound or thought-provoking story out there. I would recommend reading a few chapters to see if the humor and overall tone resonate with you before committing to the series.