A Very Popular Idol Classmate Has Taken a Liking to Me, A Person Who Doesn’t Want to Work for Whole Life

My Thoughts on A Very Popular Idol Classmate Has Taken a Liking to Me, A Person Who Doesn’t Want to Work for Whole Life

Alright, let's dive into "A Very Popular Idol Classmate Has Taken a Liking to Me, A Person Who Doesn’t Want to Work for Whole Life" – quite the mouthful, isn't it? I went in expecting a fluffy rom-com, and while it delivers on some fronts, it definitely has its quirks.

First Impressions

The premise is fairly standard: a seemingly average guy catches the eye of a popular idol. It's a trope I'm usually a sucker for, and initially, the story hooked me with its lighthearted tone. The interactions between the main characters felt genuinely sweet, and I was rooting for them. However, as the story progressed, some familiar issues started to surface.

What Works Well

I found the main characters surprisingly likable. The MC, despite his initial reluctance, isn't the stereotypical dense protagonist you often find in these stories. He has some self-esteem issues stemming from his past, but it doesn't completely define him. The female lead is also charming and supportive, and their interactions are genuinely cute. I especially appreciate the supporting cast, who add depth and humor to the narrative. The writing is also solid, and the translation is well-done, making for a smooth and enjoyable read.

Areas of Concern

One of my biggest issues is the introduction of multiple love interests. While I don't mind a bit of romantic tension, the story leans a little too heavily into the harem territory for my liking. It feels like it detracts from the main relationship and slows down the progress between the MC and the idol. I also found the "childhood promise" trope a bit overused and the MC's slowness to recognize it frustrating at times.

Final Verdict

Overall, "A Very Popular Idol Classmate Has Taken a Liking to Me, A Person Who Doesn’t Want to Work for Whole Life" is a decent read if you're looking for a lighthearted rom-com with likable characters. However, be prepared for some potentially frustrating tropes and plot developments. If you're not a fan of harems or dense protagonists, this might not be the story for you. I'd give it a cautious recommendation – go in with tempered expectations and you might find yourself enjoying the fluff.