Why Don’t You Speak?

My Thoughts on Why Don’t You Speak?

"Why Don’t You Speak?" promised angst and drama, and while it delivered on that front, my feelings are definitely mixed. This yaoi novel explores themes of arranged marriage, loss, and second chances, but the execution left me with some reservations.

First Impressions

The initial chapters certainly grabbed my attention. The setup, involving a broken engagement and the death of the MC's father, immediately plunged me into a world of emotional turmoil. I was ready for a rollercoaster of angst, and in some ways, I got it. I was interested to see how the MC would recover after all of the tragedies that had befallen him.

What Works Well

The raw emotion in the beginning is undeniably powerful. The author does a decent job of portraying the MC's initial struggles with grief and sudden responsibility. It's easy to sympathize with his situation, and I was genuinely invested in seeing him overcome his challenges. I think that the author was able to create a character that I was able to root for.

Areas of Concern

However, the plot takes some questionable turns that significantly impacted my enjoyment. The ML's actions, particularly surrounding the breakup and subsequent events, felt jarring and, at times, crossed lines that were difficult to reconcile. I struggled with the ML's motivations and found his character development unconvincing. It felt like he was being redeemed without truly earning it.

Final Verdict

"Why Don’t You Speak?" has moments of genuine emotional depth and a compelling premise. However, the execution falters due to problematic character actions and questionable plot choices. While some readers may find the angsty ride worthwhile, I found myself ultimately disappointed by the narrative's trajectory. I'd recommend approaching this one with caution and being aware of the potential triggers involved.