I Was Told To Choose 3 Ingredients for the Skill, but It Was First Come, First Served, So There Were Only a Few Leftovers. *I Noticed the Difference Between “Skill” and “Skill Source”, so I Looked Back at Those Who Created Cheat Skills in Another World and Made a Fool of Them.

My Thoughts on *I Was Told To Choose 3 Ingredients for the Skill, but It Was First Come, First Served, So There Were Only a Few Leftovers. I Noticed the Difference Between “Skill” and “Skill Source”, so I Looked Back at Those Who Created Cheat Skills in Another World and Made a Fool of Them.

First Impressions

Okay, that title is definitely a mouthful! Diving into this novel, I was prepared for a fairly standard isekai experience, and in some ways, that's exactly what I got. The premise, involving a protagonist transported to another world with a unique skill system, isn't groundbreaking. However, there's something about the way the author approaches the familiar tropes that kept me reading.

What Works Well

The skill system itself is a definite highlight. The idea of combining "skill seeds" to create unique abilities, especially when coupled with the protagonist's choice of "Hacker" as a job, opens up some interesting possibilities. I appreciated that the author seems willing to experiment with the system rather than immediately making the MC overpowered. This focus on theory-crafting and skill experimentation is a welcome change of pace. The story is easy to read, even if the chapters are short, and it’s a good way to pass the time.

Areas of Concern

While the core concept is intriguing, the execution seems to be a bit uneven. The pacing can feel jarring at times, with plot points lacking sufficient build-up or closure. I also found the characters to be somewhat underdeveloped. The MC, in particular, comes across as bland and inconsistent, lacking a strong personality. The world-building, while functional, is pretty bare-bones, leaving many questions unanswered. The motivations and actions of certain races feel poorly explained, which detracts from the overall immersion.

Final Verdict

I Was Told To Choose 3 Ingredients for the Skill… is a flawed but ultimately enjoyable read. It’s not going to win any awards for originality or masterful storytelling, but it offers a fun, if somewhat generic, isekai experience with a unique skill system at its core. If you're looking for a light, easy read with some creative potential, this might be worth checking out. Just be prepared for some inconsistencies and underdeveloped characters along the way.