Guidelines for the Perfect Goodbye Novel Review

My Thoughts on Guidelines for the Perfect Goodbye

Guidelines for the Perfect Goodbye is a web novel that certainly leaves an impression. Diving into a world of aristocracy, curses, and a protagonist fueled by vengeance, I found myself intrigued by the premise. The story centers around a female protagonist reborn with a mission to right the wrongs of her past life, a trope I'm usually wary of, but this one seemed to have a unique edge.

First Impressions

Initially, the slow pacing and heavy focus on scheming were a bit overwhelming. The sheer amount of plotting and bitter animosity created a dense atmosphere that I couldn't always devour in large chunks. However, I was quickly drawn in by the intricate web the MC begins to weave.

What Works Well

The strength of this novel lies in its cunning protagonist, Cecilia. The way she meticulously plans and executes her revenge is undeniably thrilling. I particularly enjoyed how the author took the time to flesh out the supporting characters, making the MC's retribution all the more satisfying. The translation is also well-executed, allowing me to easily follow the complex series of events. Cecilia is a complex character, neither entirely good nor evil, which made her actions feel more believable and compelling.

Areas of Concern

One aspect I found slightly concerning was the potential for a harem-like dynamic to develop. While it hasn't fully materialized, the hints of it felt somewhat unnecessary and could potentially detract from the core themes of revenge and self-reliance. Also, the author has been on hiatus for a year, so there's the real possibility the novel won't be completed.

Final Verdict

Despite some reservations, Guidelines for the Perfect Goodbye is a compelling read, especially if you enjoy stories with cunning protagonists and intricate plots. While the slow pace and heavy focus on scheming might not be for everyone, the well-developed characters and satisfying revenge make it a worthwhile experience. I'd give it a solid 3.5 out of 5 stars, with the caveat that the ongoing hiatus leaves the story's ultimate fate uncertain.