All My Beasts are Legendary Novel Review

My Thoughts on All My Beasts are Legendary

"All My Beasts are Legendary" had a lot of promise, and while I found some aspects enjoyable, ultimately, it fell short of its potential. The concept of a beast-taming academy combined with a reincarnation element initially drew me in, but the execution left me wanting more.

First Impressions

The early chapters were engaging. I liked the initial premise of the MC having a unique "Beast Editor" ability. The idea of him navigating the academy, forming bonds with his beasts, and strategically evolving them seemed like a recipe for a fun, power-fantasy adventure. However, my enthusiasm waned as the story progressed.

What Works Well

The fast-paced nature of the novel can be a positive for some. If you're looking for a quick read with constant progression, this might appeal to you. I also appreciated the MC's decisive nature and his strategic thinking, especially in the earlier arcs. The initial interactions with his first beast companion, the elf, were also quite heartwarming. At times, the author did a good job of showing how smart and ruthless the MC could be which I found enjoyable.

Areas of Concern

Unfortunately, the novel suffers from several significant issues. The pacing becomes excessively rapid, especially in the latter half. The MC's leveling felt too fast. Many subplots and characters felt underdeveloped and ultimately forgotten. The world building felt incomplete and often times illogical. The MC's cheat ability, while initially interesting, quickly became overpowered, diminishing any sense of challenge or accomplishment. Additionally, the romance felt rushed and unconvincing.

Final Verdict

"All My Beasts are Legendary" is a mixed bag. While it offers a fast-paced, power-fantasy experience with an initially intriguing premise, it's ultimately undermined by its rapid pacing, underdeveloped characters, and an increasingly overpowered MC. I can only give it a 3/5. It's an okay read if you're looking for something casual, but don't expect a deeply engaging or well-developed story.