Who Are You?

My Thoughts on Who Are You?

Who Are You? is a completed oneshot in the romance and shounen ai genres that explores themes of appearance changes and secret crushes. After diving in, I can see why it evokes such strong, yet varied, reactions from readers. It's definitely a story that sticks with you, even if it leaves you wanting more.

First Impressions

The premise immediately grabbed my attention: a character altering their appearance for their crush. It's a classic trope, but one that can be explored in really interesting ways. The story starts strong, drawing you into the characters' emotional landscape and hinting at a deeper connection waiting to be unearthed.

What Works Well

I appreciated the author's ability to create compelling characters within such a short format. Even though it's a oneshot, I felt invested in their relationship and the potential for growth. The emotional core of the story, particularly the pining and the eventual confrontation, felt authentic and relatable. I also thought the open ending was a bold choice. It allows readers to imagine their own version of the future for the characters, which can be incredibly satisfying.

Areas of Concern

While the open ending worked for me on some level, I can understand why some readers find it unsatisfying. It does feel like the first chapter of a longer story, leaving you yearning for more development and resolution. The pacing, while necessary for a oneshot, could also feel rushed at times, preventing a deeper exploration of the characters' motivations and the implications of their actions. The themes of changing oneself for someone else, while common, can also be seen as problematic depending on how it is executed.

Final Verdict

Who Are You? is an intriguing, albeit imperfect, read. It's a story with a lot of heart and potential, but one that ultimately feels like a glimpse into a larger narrative. While the open ending and the exploration of potentially problematic themes might not appeal to everyone, I think it's worth checking out if you're looking for a quick, thought-provoking romance with a touch of angst. I'd personally rate it a solid 3.5/5.