Those Years, When We Slayed Cultivators Together

My Thoughts on Those Years, When We Slayed Cultivators Together

"Those Years, When We Slayed Cultivators Together" is a novel that's left me feeling quite conflicted. It has moments of genuine charm and humor, but also some potentially serious pitfalls that make it hard to offer a wholehearted recommendation.

First Impressions

Initially, I found the story quite enjoyable. The early chapters focus on a young protagonist, Lin Xiaolu, and his group of friends. The sibling dynamic is endearing, and the world-building, though not groundbreaking, is sufficient to keep me invested. The comedic elements, especially the juxtaposition of Lin Xiaolu's childish behavior with his surprising talents, were a definite highlight.

What Works Well

The novel's strength lies in its humor. The premise of a child acting like a gang leader, strutting around and provoking powerful cultivators, is inherently funny. It's the kind of lighthearted, absurd humor that can be quite refreshing. I also appreciated the focus on the characters' relationships, particularly the bonds between siblings and friends. These interactions add a layer of warmth and relatability to the story, grounding the more fantastical elements.

Areas of Concern

However, I do have some reservations. The biggest concern revolves around the protagonist's character development, or lack thereof. While his childish antics are amusing in the early chapters, the prospect of him remaining unchanged as he grows older is worrying. Arrogance and immaturity can be funny in a child, but they become tiresome and even off-putting in a teenager or adult.

Final Verdict

Overall, "Those Years, When We Slayed Cultivators Together" is a mixed bag. It has moments of genuine humor and heartwarming character interactions, but it also faces potential issues with character development and potentially problematic plot elements. If you're looking for a lighthearted comedy with a focus on relationships, this novel might be worth a try. However, be prepared for the possibility that the humor may wear thin as the protagonist ages, and be aware of the potential for controversial plot developments. I'd say proceed with cautious optimism.