The Hero Died Before I Could Return

My Thoughts on The Hero Died Before I Could Return

"The Hero Died Before I Could Return" is definitely not your typical isekai adventure. Prepare yourself for a dive into a world of melancholy, where hope seems like a distant memory. This novel hooked me with its unique premise: the hero is already dead, and our protagonist is simply tasked with delivering his final letters. It's a setup that immediately sets the stage for something darker than your average power fantasy.

First Impressions

Initially, I wasn't sure what to expect. The synopsis hints at a regret-filled journey, but the execution is what truly matters. I was pleasantly surprised by how quickly I became invested in the protagonist's mission and the mysteries surrounding the dead hero. The world-building is subtle but effective, slowly revealing the cracks and fissures beneath a seemingly ordinary fantasy setting.

What Works Well

The protagonist is a breath of fresh air. He's not a chosen one, nor does he possess any extraordinary abilities. He is, in essence, an errand boy with a hidden past, driven by a simple desire: to return home. I found his pragmatic approach and his willingness to call out the flaws in others quite refreshing. The author does a great job of slowly unraveling his history, making me eager to learn more about his motivations and the events that shaped him. The tragic backstories of the heroines are well written.

Areas of Concern

While the novel excels at creating a bleak and depressing atmosphere, it can become overwhelming at times. The constant misery and suffering might not be for everyone. I can see why some readers might find it too much to handle, especially if they're looking for a more uplifting story. The ending may also be a point of contention for some, as it is considered to be abrupt and leaves some loose ends untied.

Final Verdict

"The Hero Died Before I Could Return" is a compelling, albeit depressing, read. If you're seeking a feel-good story, steer clear. However, if you're drawn to tragic characters, intricate mysteries, and a world steeped in despair, this novel might just be a hidden gem. I recommend going into it with an open mind and a willingness to embrace the darkness. Just be prepared for an emotional rollercoaster.