A Depressed Kendo Player Possesses a Bastard Aristocrat

My Thoughts on A Depressed Kendo Player Possesses a Bastard Aristocrat

"A Depressed Kendo Player Possesses a Bastard Aristocrat" is definitely a web novel that elicits strong reactions, and I can see why. It's a story that grapples with heavy themes, and whether it succeeds seems to depend heavily on the reader's expectations and personal experiences.

First Impressions

The premise itself is a bit of a tightrope walk: a character who dies by suicide is transported into the body of another troubled individual. Right away, that's a lot to unpack, and I think the story's execution of this concept is where opinions diverge. Some find the initial setup promising, while others are immediately put off by what they perceive as a potentially harmful message.

What Works Well

Many readers praise the novel's portrayal of depression, highlighting its accuracy and relatability. The raw, unflinching depiction of the MC's internal struggles seems to resonate with those who have experienced similar mental health challenges. The EX-rank ability that is gifted to the MC is specifically tailored to prevent the MC from feeling suicidal, it is a interesting concept that is further explored in the novel. There's also appreciation for the gradual progress the MC makes, acknowledging that overcoming depression isn't a linear journey. The side characters and their relationships with the MC also seem to be a strong point, offering a support system that feels genuine. Some have described the novel as "guided catharsis" with the ability to help process sorrow and grief.

Areas of Concern

However, the novel's strengths are also its weaknesses. The heavy focus on depression can become overwhelming, making for a relentlessly gloomy reading experience. The "edgy" tone and occasionally forced drama can feel contrived to some, while others find the pacing too fast, hindering character development. The system is a tool almost exclusive to the MC, but it's also a plot device. The system is flexible and sometimes seems to have a personality of its own, which may hinder the experience for some. Some also find the female characters to be a bit shallow and underdeveloped.

Final Verdict

"A Depressed Kendo Player Possesses a Bastard Aristocrat" is a web novel with a clear, albeit challenging, focus: exploring the complexities of mental illness and the long road to recovery. If you're looking for a lighthearted escape, this isn't it. But if you're willing to delve into a darker narrative with a protagonist grappling with profound trauma, this might be a worthwhile read. Just be prepared for a potentially heavy and emotionally taxing experience.