I Am A Prodigy

My Thoughts on I Am A Prodigy

Alright, let's dive into "I Am A Prodigy." This web novel certainly sparked some strong opinions, and after sifting through what readers have to say, I've got a pretty clear picture of what you're getting into.

First Impressions

Honestly, the premise sounds like something I'd usually enjoy: a protagonist with a system that allows him to master skills quickly. It hits that wish-fulfillment sweet spot that can be fun. However, it seems like the execution is where things start to fall apart. A few readers mentioned being drawn in initially, only to be disappointed later on, which is never a good sign.

What Works Well

It's tough to find a consensus on what this novel does exceptionally well. A few readers pointed out that the beginning was engaging, and the fast-paced nature of the early chapters kept them hooked. One reviewer even compared it favorably to "I'm Really a Superstar," suggesting that if you enjoy that kind of vibe, you might find something to like here. Also, one reader mentioned liking the main character's attitude, finding him to be an accurate representation of someone with max talent.

Areas of Concern

Okay, here's where things get a bit dicey. The biggest issue seems to be the heavy-handed nationalism. Several readers felt that it crossed the line into outright disdain for other cultures, particularly Japan and Korea. This made them uncomfortable and ultimately soured their experience. The writing and plot also seem to be problematic, with many finding the logic questionable, character motivations weak, and the overall story directionless. The harem aspect was criticized for being shallow and forced. I also noticed some concerns regarding the author's portrayal of female characters, with some calling it sexist.

Final Verdict

"I Am A Prodigy" is a tough sell. While the initial premise might be appealing, the execution seems to stumble in several key areas. The heavy nationalism, questionable plot logic, and shallow characters appear to be major drawbacks. If you're a die-hard fan of the genre and can overlook these issues, you might find some fleeting enjoyment. However, based on the overwhelming negative feedback, I'd recommend exploring other options first. There are plenty of web novels out there that offer similar wish-fulfillment without the problematic elements.