The Player Hides His Past

My Thoughts on The Player Hides His Past

"The Player Hides His Past" is a web novel that's been on my radar for a while, especially since I've seen the manhwa adaptation getting a lot of buzz. Diving into the original, I found a story with an intriguing premise, even if the execution has some quirks. It's a blend of action, comedy, and fantasy, and while it might not be perfect, there's definitely something here that's capturing readers' attention.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the concept of two MCs sharing a single body. Lee Hoyeol and Grandfell Arpheus Claudi Romeo (what a name!) offer a unique dynamic. The chuunibyou setting is evident from the start, and the story leans into the misunderstandings that arise from it. It's clear the author is aiming for humor, and in the early chapters, it mostly lands. However, I could also see how the pacing might feel slow for some, especially with the amount of internal monologue.

What Works Well

The core strength of this novel lies in its characters, particularly the relationship between Hoyeol and Grandfell. Their interactions are entertaining, and the slow reveal of Grandfell's past and lore adds a layer of depth that keeps me invested. I appreciate that the author doesn't just use the "two MCs" concept as a simple gag; it's a fundamental part of the plot that unfolds as the story progresses. The power fantasy element is also enjoyable, especially if you embrace the chuunibyou setting. The MC's growth, even if somewhat rapid, feels earned as he navigates the challenges thrown his way.

Areas of Concern

While the premise is strong, I do have some reservations about the execution. The writing style can be a bit uneven, with frequent POV switches and lengthy monologues that sometimes bog down the pacing. I can see how the humor might become repetitive over hundreds of chapters, and some readers might find the misunderstandings trope tiresome. Also, I noticed that some readers felt the translation to be a bit rough around the edges, with some awkward phrasing and formatting issues. I also agree with other reviewers that the manhwa adaptation is better, full of comedy and mc's inner memes, it's perfectly fits and funny to read.

Final Verdict

"The Player Hides His Past" is a flawed but ultimately enjoyable web novel. If you're looking for a lighthearted power fantasy with a unique character dynamic and don't mind some pacing issues, it's worth checking out. However, if you prefer a more polished and visually engaging experience, the manhwa adaptation might be a better fit. Despite its shortcomings, I'm intrigued enough to continue reading and see where the story goes.