I Was Invited to Join the Country as a Warrior from Another World, but I Refused and Decided to Start as a Soldier

My Thoughts on I Was Invited to Join the Country as a Warrior from Another World, but I Refused and Decided to Start as a Soldier

First Impressions

The title is a mouthful, but it immediately grabbed my attention. I'm always drawn to stories where the protagonist makes unconventional choices, especially in the overdone "isekai" genre. The premise—a refusal to be a chosen one and instead choosing to climb the ranks—is definitely intriguing. I dove in hoping for a fresh take on the transported-to-another-world trope.

What Works Well

Initially, the story does a solid job of creating a believable world and a protagonist who, while perhaps a bit too nice, isn't overly overpowered. I appreciated that the MC isn't instantly the strongest person around and has to work his way up from the bottom. The early chapters focus on his growth and integration into the military, and this slow-burn approach to power progression kept me engaged. The political intrigue and world-building elements are also well-executed, offering a decent alternative to the standard isekai power fantasy.

Areas of Concern

This dramatic shift in direction is a huge red flag for me. It sounds completely out of sync with the initial premise and character development. A sudden genre shift like that can be incredibly jarring and alienate readers who were invested in the original storyline. The idea of the MC becoming a "toy to the gods" also raises concerns about the plot losing its focus and becoming unnecessarily convoluted. This sudden deviation leads me to believe the author may be struggling to maintain a consistent vision for the story, which is a shame because the start was so promising.

Final Verdict

"I Was Invited to Join the Country as a Warrior from Another World, but I Refused and Decided to Start as a Soldier" shows promise with its initial premise and world-building. However, the reported plot twist significantly diminishes my enthusiasm. If you're willing to risk investing time in a story that might drastically change direction, then give it a shot. But be warned: you might end up wishing it had ended at chapter 123. For me, the potential for a disjointed narrative makes it difficult to fully recommend.