I Couldn’t Tell You Who It Was Novel Review

My Thoughts on I Couldn’t Tell You Who It Was

"I Couldn’t Tell You Who It Was" is a novel that truly took me by surprise. Going in, I expected a fairly standard horror romance, but what I found was a much deeper, psychologically complex story that explores the darker side of love and obsession. It's not a light read by any means, but it's a compelling one that has stuck with me long after finishing.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the mystery surrounding the MC and his past. The story quickly establishes a creepy atmosphere, and I found myself eager to uncover the secrets of the mansion and the strange events that plague the protagonist. The early chapters do a great job of setting the stage for the psychological horror to come. I was a bit thrown off by the cast of characters, and found it hard to keep track of who everyone was which made it hard to follow at times.

What Works Well

The novel excels in its exploration of psychological themes. The MC's guilt, depression, and the overall sense of unease are masterfully portrayed. I found myself deeply invested in his journey, even as it became increasingly dark and disturbing. The horror elements are genuinely unsettling, and the plot twists kept me on the edge of my seat. The romance, when it does appear, is not a source of comfort but rather another layer of complexity and tragedy. The author does a wonderful job of depicting the different versions of love that can occur between people. The story is well written overall, and the ending is satisfying.

Areas of Concern

While I ultimately enjoyed the novel, it's definitely not for everyone. The story contains instances of non-con and deals with heavy themes that may be triggering for some readers. The chapters are very short, and the story can be confusing at times due to the similar names of the characters.

Final Verdict

Despite its dark themes and potentially triggering content, "I Couldn’t Tell You Who It Was" is a well-crafted and thought-provoking novel. It's a unique blend of horror, mystery, and psychological drama that explores the complexities of love and obsession. If you're looking for a story that will challenge you and stay with you long after you finish reading, I highly recommend giving this one a try. Just be prepared for a heavy and emotionally intense experience.