I Became An Academy Spearman

My Thoughts on I Became An Academy Spearman

I dove into "I Became An Academy Spearman" with a mix of excitement and trepidation, given the mixed reception I'd seen floating around. With its blend of academy life, action, and a potential harem, it seemed like a recipe for either a delightful escape or a frustrating slog. After spending some time with it, I've landed somewhere in the middle.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the premise. A protagonist transmigrating into a world where his spearman class is considered weak, forcing him to overcome the odds through sheer hard work? Intriguing! The early chapters held promise, showcasing a protagonist determined to improve, even if his starting point was abysmal. I appreciated the focus on dialogue and the MC's quick thinking.

What Works Well

The combat system and fighting are quite interesting, and the author put some thought into how it all works. I liked the idea of the MC pushing himself to the absolute limit to improve, and the initial focus on his dedication was compelling. Some readers also praised the art, which is always a plus. Also, the MC isn't dense, and is actually focused on what he needs to do.

Areas of Concern

Unfortunately, as I progressed, I found myself agreeing with some of the common criticisms. The pacing is glacial. A single fight could drag on for an excessive number of chapters, and conversations seemed to take forever. The slow pacing is what killed it for me. The characters also felt immature, with interactions that often came across as cringe-worthy. The MC's sudden obsession with building a harem, despite his supposed focus on survival, felt forced and out of character. The "hardworking fetish" also felt overdone, with characters constantly amazed by the MC's efforts, as if no one had ever tried hard before.

Final Verdict

"I Became An Academy Spearman" has potential, but it's ultimately bogged down by pacing issues, immature character interactions, and an over-reliance on harem tropes. While the initial premise and the MC's dedication are appealing, the slow burn and repetitive scenarios make it a difficult recommendation. If you're a die-hard fan of slow-paced, dialogue-heavy academy novels with a focus on romance, you might find something to enjoy here. Otherwise, proceed with caution.