How To Live As An Academy Extra Villain Novel Review

My Thoughts on How To Live As An Academy Extra Villain

I've been diving into "How To Live As An Academy Extra Villain," and I have some thoughts. This novel definitely has a particular flavor, and whether you'll enjoy it really depends on your preferences for the genre. It's a reincarnation story where our protagonist finds himself in the body of a villainous extra in a magical academy setting, a premise I'm always a sucker for.

First Impressions

Initially, I was intrigued. The opening chapters are well-written, and the translation quality is noticeably high, something that always earns a novel points in my book. I appreciated that the protagonist seemed calm and calculating, not just another wimpy pushover. However, that feeling didn't last for everyone, as some readers felt the story lost direction and became aimless.

What Works Well

What I found most enjoyable was the focus on slice-of-life elements and character interactions. The heroines, in particular, seem to be a strong point. Many readers praised their fleshed-out personalities and character growth, which is a major plus. The MC's active dislike of the original protagonist is also a refreshing change from the norm. I also appreciated that the MC's transformation from a "fat bully weakling" is handled realistically, with gradual progress and attention to his health.

Areas of Concern

Despite the positives, I did notice some recurring criticisms. Pacing seems to be an issue for some. The story can feel slow, with not much of an overarching plot to drive the narrative forward. I can see how some readers might find it boring, especially if they're expecting constant action and thrilling fights.

The density of the protagonist is another point of contention. While some might find it amusing, others might find it frustrating how oblivious he is to the affections of the heroines. Some readers also felt that the MC's initial determination to act as a villain crumbles too easily, which can be disappointing if you're expecting a truly villainous protagonist. Also, the quality of the "romance" is contentious and often referred to as "cringe."

Final Verdict

Overall, "How To Live As An Academy Extra Villain" is a decent read, especially if you enjoy slice-of-life academy stories with a focus on character interactions and a harem. However, be aware of the pacing issues and the potentially frustrating density of the protagonist. If you're looking for a fast-paced action story with a truly villainous MC, this might not be the novel for you. I'd recommend stacking up a good number of chapters before diving in, so you can get a better feel for the story's direction and decide if it's to your taste.