Everything Was a Mistake

My Thoughts on Everything Was a Mistake

"Everything Was a Mistake" certainly throws you for a loop. As a fan of the shoujo genre, especially stories with a villainess twist, I was intrigued. It's a story that seems to promise a fresh take on familiar tropes, and while it delivers in some ways, it also stumbles in others.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the premise of a villainess and a potentially villainous male lead. That's a dynamic I can really sink my teeth into! The story dives right into the thick of things, quickly establishing the childhood connection and the underlying tension. It’s a quick recap that throws you into the deep end, which can be a bit jarring, but it definitely piqued my interest.

What Works Well

The character psychology is a strong point. The story delves into the realistic reactions and motivations of its characters, especially the male lead. The male lead is truly terrifying and I can't decide whether or not this is a romance or a horror novel. The angst is strong with this one. It's not a standard villainess isekai trope. Also, many readers praised the plot for being different from normal villainous ones. I like how the story behind and doesn't have too much comedy.

Areas of Concern

My biggest issue, and one that seems to be echoed by many, is the translation quality. It can be a real struggle to follow the plot when the writing is riddled with errors. It really distracts you from the plot and makes you wonder if you actually understand the story correctly. Also, the novel is full of misunderstandings, to the point that you want to enter and help the FL. Another concern is the communication. The misunderstandings could be solved if they just used their brains to figure out that at their age communication is key to healthy relationships.

Final Verdict

"Everything Was a Mistake" has a lot of potential. The unique premise, the complex characters, and the psychological depth make it a compelling read. However, the poor translation and the frustrating misunderstandings hold it back. I'd recommend giving it a try, especially if you enjoy angsty stories and can overlook the translation issues. However, it might be worth checking out the manhwa adaptation instead, as some readers have found it easier to follow. Overall, I'd give it a cautious recommendation.