Alchemist on an Isolated Island -Because I Was Sent to an Isolated Island During My School Trip, I Will Become an Alchemist and Improve My Living Environment-

My Thoughts on Alchemist on an Isolated Island -Because I Was Sent to an Isolated Island During My School Trip, I Will Become an Alchemist and Improve My Living Environment-

First Impressions

Okay, the title is a mouthful, I admit! But beneath the surface, "Alchemist on an Isolated Island" presents an interesting premise: a seemingly anti-social protagonist, suddenly thrust into a survival situation after being transported to another world during a school trip. The initial concept of using alchemy to improve his living conditions definitely piqued my interest. It felt like a potentially unique blend of survival, fantasy, and a bit of problem-solving.

What Works Well

The strongest aspect of this novel, in my opinion, lies in the protagonist's resourcefulness. I appreciate the creative problem-solving as he attempts to use his alchemic abilities to overcome the challenges of surviving on the island. The idea that his experiments don't always succeed adds a layer of realism that makes the story more engaging. It's not just a smooth ride to godhood; there's genuine trial and error involved, which is refreshing.

Areas of Concern

However, there are aspects of the story that gave me pause. The introduction of the harem, facilitated by the system itself, felt a bit forced. The system sometimes feels a little too convenient, bordering on a deus ex machina, which could potentially undermine the protagonist's ingenuity in the long run. I worry that the story might rely too heavily on the system providing the exact skill needed at the exact moment, rather than on the protagonist's own creativity and resourcefulness.

Final Verdict

"Alchemist on an Isolated Island" has potential, particularly in its focus on creative problem-solving and alchemic experimentation. However, the somewhat forced harem introduction and the occasionally convenient system mechanics are definite drawbacks. The controversial decision in the later chapters might be a deal-breaker for some. Overall, I'd say it's a mixed bag. If you enjoy survival stories with a touch of alchemy and don't mind a system-driven narrative and a harem, it might be worth a try, but be prepared for some potentially frustrating plot developments.