The Idol Training Simulation I Messed Up

My Thoughts on The Idol Training Simulation I Messed Up

Okay, so I dove into "The Idol Training Simulation I Messed Up" with a healthy dose of curiosity. The premise alone – a protagonist transmigrating into a game she designed, now responsible for the idol group she mishandled – was enough to pique my interest. And after spending some time with it, I have some thoughts.

First Impressions

Initially, I was drawn in by the unique twist on the idol genre. We've seen plenty of "become an idol or die trying" stories, but this felt different. The MC isn't striving for her own fame; she's grappling with the consequences of her in-game decisions and trying to salvage the careers (and lives) of the idols she created. That immediately sets it apart.

What Works Well

One of the strongest aspects is the absence of typical system tropes. Instead of a deluge of stats and deus ex machina abilities, the system provides previews and real-time data, like fan interest and popularity indexes. This allows the MC (and us readers) to understand the impact of her choices in a more grounded way.

I also appreciated the realism injected into the narrative. The story doesn't shy away from portraying the harsh realities of the idol industry, including stagnation, poor management, and the fleeting nature of fame. The MC's constant apologies and awareness of her past mistakes resonate because they stem from a genuine understanding of the damage she inflicted. The author does a great job of portraying the other characters' POVs, adding layers to the story.

Areas of Concern

While the lack of typical system elements is a plus for me, the novel does focus more on the idol group than the MC herself. The fact that the MC forced the boys to stagnate for 5 years is a major point of contention.

Final Verdict

Overall, "The Idol Training Simulation I Messed Up" offers a refreshing and thought-provoking take on the idol genre. It's a story about responsibility, redemption, and the complexities of the entertainment industry. While it might not be perfect, its unique premise, realistic portrayal of idol life, and compelling character dynamics make it a worthwhile read.