Skeleton Master

My Thoughts on Skeleton Master

Alright, let's dive into Skeleton Master. With a 3.6/5 rating, I went in with a cautiously optimistic mindset. Action, adventure, fantasy with game elements? Sounds like my kind of party! But as always, the devil's in the details.

First Impressions

My initial impression mirrors some of the reservations I've seen floating around. The opening feels a bit… rushed. The protagonist's transition from a bleak real life to sudden VRMMORPG reincarnation felt a little clunky. It's the classic "second chance" trope, but the setup lacked a certain spark to truly hook me. I wanted a bit more depth, a stronger emotional connection to the character's past struggles to really invest in his new beginning.

What Works Well

Despite my initial hesitations, the core concept has potential. The idea of a character choosing the seemingly "worst" class, the necromancer, is intriguing. There's a built-in underdog narrative that I always enjoy. We all love seeing the weak become strong, especially when they do it with a bit of unconventional flair. The tags like "blacksmith" and "crafting" also suggest a potentially interesting system where the MC might have to work his way up, using his skills to overcome the challenges of being a necromancer.

Areas of Concern

My biggest concern is the risk of falling into familiar VRMMORPG tropes. The fear of "copy-pasta" plot structures and endless filler content is real. The novel needs to differentiate itself, inject some originality into the class and the game mechanics. The characters need to be more than just cardboard cutouts, the world needs to feel alive, and the plot needs to offer more than just a grind to the top of the game ranking system.

Final Verdict

Skeleton Master has potential, but it needs to overcome some early hurdles. If it can deliver a unique take on the necromancer class, build a compelling world, and avoid the common pitfalls of the VRMMORPG genre, it could be a fun read. As it stands, I'd say proceed with caution and be prepared for a familiar, albeit potentially enjoyable, journey.