I’m Not Your Fated Guide, But… Novel Review

My Thoughts on I’m Not Your Fated Guide, But…

"I’m Not Your Fated Guide, But…" is a ride! It’s a blend of action, comedy, and romance set in a guide/esper world that kept me hooked despite a few quirks. The ongoing translation had me impatient at times, but the core story definitely shines through.

First Impressions

Going in, I wasn't sure what to expect. Guideverse stories can be hit or miss, and some of the tags (like "bickering couple" and "cold love interests") made me a little wary. However, the comedic undertones and the promise of character growth piqued my interest. The initial impression of the ML being a typical, detached esper quickly faded as the story unfolded, revealing a more complex and, dare I say, endearing character.

What Works Well

The dynamic between the MC and ML is definitely a highlight. Their constant bickering, which often escalates into actual fights, is strangely endearing. It's their way of communicating and working through their issues. I also appreciated that the story doesn't fall into the typical "esper controls guide" trope. They are equals, respecting each other's autonomy and supporting each other through their individual traumas. The plot itself, while seemingly straightforward, has some surprising depth and emotional resonance. I found myself unexpectedly moved by their journey, especially as their relationship organically developed. The focus on mental health alongside the physical aspects of their connection was a refreshing change of pace.

Areas of Concern

⚠️ Spoiler Warning ⚠️

While I enjoyed the story immensely, there were a couple of things that gave me pause. The ML's actions later in the story, particularly how he treats his sister and allies, felt like a step back from his earlier development. His lack of remorse in those moments was frustrating. Also, while their fighting dynamic is entertaining, there were instances where the MC's actions felt excessive, even after the ML stopped fighting back.

Final Verdict

Despite those minor issues, "I’m Not Your Fated Guide, But…" is a worthwhile read. The engaging plot, the unique dynamic between the leads, and the surprisingly emotional depth make it stand out in the guideverse genre. If you're looking for a story that blends humor, action, and romance with a touch of angst, I highly recommend giving this one a try. Just be prepared for some bickering, a few tears, and a whole lot of heart.