I Thought It Was a Fantasy Romance, but It’s a Horror Story Novel Review

My Thoughts on I Thought It Was a Fantasy Romance, but It’s a Horror Story

"I Thought It Was a Fantasy Romance, but It’s a Horror Story" is a title that certainly grabs your attention, and after diving in, I can confirm it lives up to the promise of genre-bending fun. The premise alone – a romance-savvy protagonist trying to force a horror world into her preferred narrative – is wonderfully unique.

First Impressions

Initially, I was hooked by the comedic undertones and the sheer audacity of the main character. She's a veteran of the romance fantasy genre, and that meta-awareness adds a layer of entertainment as she navigates the decidedly un-romantic horrors around her. The European-inspired setting and cross-dressing element were also intriguing additions that kept me invested.

What Works Well

The biggest strength of this novel is undoubtedly the protagonist. Her "carefree" attitude, coupled with her surprisingly effective communication skills, makes her a joy to follow. I found myself constantly chuckling at her attempts to steer the narrative away from impending doom and towards a happily-ever-after. The male lead's transformation into a "sweet and cuddly puppy" is also a delightful payoff to her efforts. It's a testament to the author's skill that they can blend horror and romance so seamlessly, creating a story that is both funny and engaging.

Areas of Concern

While I enjoyed the overall experience, the ending left me with a slightly unsettling feeling. The protagonist's perception of the male lead felt a bit detached, almost as if she loved a fictional character rather than a real person. This contributed to the sense that she might be trapped in an illusion, which, while thematically appropriate, left me wanting a bit more emotional depth.

Final Verdict

Overall, "I Thought It Was a Fantasy Romance, but It’s a Horror Story" is a refreshing and entertaining read. It's a clever subversion of both the romance fantasy and horror genres, with a protagonist you can't help but root for. While the ending might leave you with some lingering questions and a slightly unsettling feeling, the journey is well worth it. I'd recommend it to anyone looking for a unique and darkly comedic fantasy novel.