I Think The Genre Has Changed

My Thoughts on I Think The Genre Has Changed

"I Think The Genre Has Changed" presents an interesting premise: a reincarnation into a high school romance set within a hunter/dungeon world. The blend of genres, including action, fantasy, romance, school life, and yaoi, definitely piqued my interest. However, after delving into the available chapters, I've found the execution to be a bit of a mixed bag.

First Impressions

Initially, the story does have a certain charm. The idea of a protagonist navigating a world that's both familiar (high school) and fantastical (magic, monsters) is appealing. I was ready to dive into a cliché-filled but fun ride, but I was immediately thrown off by the heavy narration. It felt like I was being told what was happening rather than shown, which made it difficult to connect with the characters and the world.

What Works Well

Despite some flaws, the underlying plot does hold potential. The concept of the MC grappling with his new reality, especially the emotional weight of inhabiting someone else's body, is intriguing. There's also a hint of promise in the world-building, with mentions of abilities, monsters, and a ranker system. The initial setup of the story is interesting, and some readers may find enjoyment in the evolving relationships between the main character and the potential love interests.

Areas of Concern

The biggest issue, and one that many readers seem to share, is the translation quality. There are reports of character genders and names being mixed up, dialogue that's confusing and nonsensical, and an overall lack of polish that makes it difficult to follow the story. This is a major barrier to enjoying the novel, as it disrupts the flow and makes it hard to become invested.

Beyond the translation, the writing style itself seems to be a point of contention. Some feel that the author relies too heavily on internal monologues and exposition, which slows down the pace and detracts from the action and character interactions. The abruptness of events and the lack of meaningful plot progression also contribute to a sense of awkwardness and frustration.

Final Verdict

While "I Think The Genre Has Changed" has an interesting premise and some potential for engaging romance and fantasy elements, the poor translation quality and uneven writing style ultimately hold it back. If the translation were to improve significantly, and if the author were to focus on showing rather than telling, this novel could be much more enjoyable. As it stands, I'd recommend approaching this one with caution.