I Became the Dark Knight in the Game Novel Review

My Thoughts on I Became the Dark Knight in the Game

"I Became the Dark Knight in the Game" has been quite the ride so far, and I'm eager to share my thoughts. The premise alone grabbed my attention: a protagonist reborn as a half-undead character in a game world, grappling with morality and rediscovering his humanity. It sounded like a recipe for a complex and engaging story, and for the most part, it delivers.

First Impressions

Initially, I was thrown right into the action, which I appreciated. The story doesn't waste time with lengthy introductions, instead dropping you into the protagonist's journey mid-stride. This "show, don't tell" approach is refreshing, immediately establishing the grim and mysterious world. I found myself intrigued by the MC's internal conflict between his undead instincts and his desire to cling to his human side.

What Works Well

The characters, especially the side characters, are a definite highlight. They possess depth and feel like real people with their own motivations, not just cardboard cutouts. The author does an excellent job of giving them distinct personalities and stories, making them feel like integral parts of the world. I also found the slow-burn nature of the story appealing. It's not a rush to power, but a gradual progression that feels earned. I particularly enjoyed the moral dilemmas the MC faces and his evolving approach to justice. The writing is generally strong, and the translation is well done, making for a smooth and enjoyable reading experience.

Areas of Concern

One aspect that I found slightly jarring was the integration of game-like elements into the dark fantasy setting. While I appreciate the unique blend, the presence of levels and shrines sometimes clashed with the overall tone, making it difficult to fully immerse myself in the world's grittiness. Also, the MC's inhumane nature and ambiguous morality may not appeal to all readers. While some appreciate the journey of rediscovering and losing connections, others may find the lack of clear moral direction off-putting.

Final Verdict

Overall, "I Became the Dark Knight in the Game" is a compelling and well-written novel with a unique premise and interesting characters. While the integration of game elements and the MC's ambiguous morality may not be for everyone, the story's strengths far outweigh its weaknesses. If you enjoy dark fantasy with a focus on character development and moral dilemmas, I highly recommend giving this one a try.